Emma holding her newborn baby after her planned caesarean birth at Lister Hospital in Stevenage.
| | |

Planned C-section birth story at Lister Hospital: making informed decisions when pregnancy takes an unexpected turn

I think it’s important to remember that it is powerful to make your own informed choice about your care and birth. Often it can feel like an elective C-section is the kind of birth that you’re ‘not supposed’ to want. Being confident and informed about different types of birth and my options allowed me to make the choice that was right for us.

Emma – CubCare Antenatal Course and pregnancy yoga attendee, welwyn hatfield. Birthed at lister hospital.

When Emma reached 39 weeks, an ultrasound estimated that her baby was measuring almost off the top of the growth chart.

She was offered two options: induction that evening or a planned caesarean.

The baby was eventually born weighing 7lb 12oz.

This isn’t a story about scans being “good” or “bad”. It’s a story about understanding what scan results can—and can’t—tell us, and making informed decisions when pregnancy takes an unexpected turn.

Emma attended my antenatal course while expecting her first baby. During her pregnancy she experienced threatened preterm labour, repeated trips to triage, conflicting advice from different healthcare professionals and growth scans that seemed to tell a different story each time.

Like so many pregnancies, this wasn’t a straightforward journey from positive pregnancy test to labour. New information emerged, plans changed and different decisions needed to be made along the way.

One of the reasons I love sharing real birth stories is that they remind us pregnancy isn’t a test where there’s one “right” answer.

It’s a series of conversations, choices and moments where understanding your options can help you decide what’s right for you and your baby.

Emma’s story is a wonderful example of that. It also highlights why it’s so important to understand both the strengths and the limitations of the information we’re given. Growth scans are an incredibly useful tool, but like every test in pregnancy, they have limitations. Knowing what those limitations are doesn’t mean ignoring the results—it means putting them into context when making decisions about your care.

You may also want to read:
→ How birth actually works: a clear guide to labour physiology for modern parents

→ Lister Hospital Maternity Statistics: What the data shows and why it matters

→ Fast labour with Hypermobility Spectrum Disorder (HSD): Gemma’s Lister Hospital birth story

Emma holding her newborn baby after her planned caesarean birth at Lister Hospital in Stevenage.
Emma and Leo shortly after his planned caesarean birth at Lister Hospital. Shared with permission.

Threatened preterm labour at 25 weeks

Emma writes:

“I read lots of birth stories while I was pregnant but don’t remember any similar to ours. I think it’s really important to hear a range of stories and that all kinds of birth can be positive when you are able to make the best choices for you and your baby.

At 25 weeks I had an episode of threatened preterm labour. I was admitted to Lister and there was talk of having to emergency transfer to a hospital with specialist neonatal care. Looking back now it’s quite scary, but at the time I think I was just in shock.

I stayed on the ward for a few days for observation, but luckily nothing progressed and I was eventually able to go home and carry on as normal.”

For many families, this would have been the point where the rest of the pregnancy felt very uncertain.

Threatened preterm labour doesn’t always lead to a premature birth, but it does mean your maternity team will take things seriously while they assess what’s happening. Depending on how many weeks pregnant you are and what they find, this may involve monitoring, medication, admission to hospital or, occasionally, discussions about transfer to a hospital with a higher level of neonatal care.

If your baby is expected to need specialist care after birth, your team may recommend transferring you before labour begins, if it’s safe to do so. This allows your baby to be born in a hospital with the right facilities already in place.

Lister hospital has a Neonatal Unit, so if your baby is born and requires medical attention it is likely they they will be able to stay on site. Some medical situations require more complex care, and more specialist teams, above what can be offered at Lister.

Thankfully, Emma’s contractions settled and she was able to continue her pregnancy.

What happens if your baby might arrive very early and you’re planning to give birth at Lister Hospital?

One of the things Emma mentions is the possibility of being transferred to another hospital. If you’ve never thought about neonatal care before, that can sound incredibly frightening.

The good news is that these decisions are made to make sure babies receive the right level of care for their gestation and medical needs.

Lister Hospital has a neonatal unit and cares for many babies who need extra support after birth. However, babies expected to arrive very prematurely, or who are likely to need more specialised care, may be transferred before birth to a hospital with a Neonatal Intensive Care Unit (NICU).

Across the East of England, specialist neonatal intensive care is provided at centres including The Rosie Hospital in Cambridge, Luton and Dunstable University Hospital, and Princess Alexandra Hospital in Harlow. Which hospital is recommended depends on your baby’s needs and which units have capacity at the time.

Fortunately, Emma’s contractions settled and she was able to continue her pregnancy, but her story is a reminder that maternity teams are always balancing the needs of both parent and baby when making these decisions.

When every hospital visit seems to bring a different answer

Emma continues:

“I was admitted once more for threatened preterm labour and made so many trips up to triage for painful contractions and Braxton Hicks.

I was often given conflicting advice or responses. It was ‘just Braxton Hicks, not contractions’. I was told Braxton Hicks aren’t painful (while I was in pain!), that Braxton Hicks wouldn’t show on the monitor (while the monitor showed contractions), and that Braxton Hicks couldn’t be regular, even though mine often came in the classic three contractions in ten minutes pattern for hours.

I was told to come back if it happened again, but then turned away because I wasn’t ‘in enough pain’ for them to check me.

It left me feeling anxious, overwhelmed and completely out of control.”

If you’ve ever left an appointment feeling more confused than when you arrived, you’re certainly not alone.

Pregnancy isn’t always straightforward, and healthcare professionals are often making decisions based on the information available at that moment. Different clinicians may interpret the same symptoms slightly differently, particularly when they’re trying to work out whether labour is beginning or whether something else is causing your contractions.

That doesn’t make those conflicting messages any less frustrating when you’re the person experiencing them.

One of the reasons antenatal education is so valuable is that it gives you a foundation of understanding before you’re in those situations. You don’t need to become the expert in the room, but understanding what’s happening in your body and knowing what questions to ask can help you feel more involved in decisions about your care, even when there isn’t one simple answer.ges.

Ultrasound scan being performed during pregnancy to assess a baby's growth and estimated fetal weight.
Growth scans provide valuable information during pregnancy, but estimated fetal weight is just one part of the wider clinical picture.

Growth scans, uncertainty and making informed decisions

Emma writes:

“I was offered growth scans, and it was lovely to be able to see our baby regularly. But looking back, the growth scans caused a lot of extra worry.

We were first told he wasn’t growing.

Then that he’d caught up.

Then that he was big.

Then that he was too big.

At my final growth scan, at 39 weeks, we were told he was almost off the top of the growth chart and getting bigger too quickly.

I was advised to either have an induction that evening or schedule a planned caesarean.”

I think this part of Emma’s story highlights something that’s really important to understand about pregnancy care.

Growth scans are an incredibly valuable tool, particularly when there are concerns about a baby’s growth or well-being. They provide information that simply wasn’t available to previous generations.

At the same time, it’s important to understand that estimating fetal weight by ultrasound isn’t an exact science. Recent research suggests that around two-thirds of third-trimester estimates are within 10% of a baby’s actual birth weight, but ultrasound also has recognised margins of error and tends to overestimate birth weight on average.

But they’re still estimates.

Like every test in pregnancy, they have strengths and limitations. Understanding both is an important part of making informed decisions.

Ultrasound measurements become increasingly difficult later in pregnancy. While they’re sometimes close to a baby’s actual birth weight, recognised margins of error mean that some babies predicted to be very large are born much smaller, while others predicted to be small are larger than expected.

That doesn’t mean growth scans shouldn’t be used.

It doesn’t mean their findings should be ignored.

It does mean that an estimated weight should be considered alongside the wider clinical picture, your individual circumstances, your preferences and the available evidence before decisions are made about your care.

One of the reasons I encourage parents to understand how different tests work during pregnancy is because every result has context. Knowing what a result can tell us—and what it can’t—helps you ask informed questions and feel more confident during conversations with your maternity team.

Understanding the evidence behind growth scans

Research has consistently shown that estimating a baby’s weight by ultrasound becomes less accurate as pregnancy progresses.

One 2023 study comparing ultrasound estimated fetal weight with babies’ actual birth weights found differences ranging from 17.5% below to 38.3% above the baby’s eventual birth weight.

Other research has shown that relatively small differences in estimated weight can make a baby’s growth appear to cross centile lines, even when normal measurement variation is the explanation.

This doesn’t make ultrasound “wrong”. It simply reminds us that estimated fetal weight is one piece of information rather than an exact measurement, which is why results should always be interpreted alongside the wider clinical picture.

It’s also worth remembering that the numbers you see on a report don’t exist in isolation. They need to be interpreted using fetal growth charts, and different charts don’t always classify babies in the same way. A large 2026 study of more than 3.2 million NHS births found substantial variation in how babies were classified as small for gestational age depending on which growth chart was used. The authors concluded that the choice of chart can influence which babies receive additional monitoring and intervention, highlighting just how important interpretation is alongside the measurements themselves.

Midwife measuring fundal height during a routine pregnancy appointment.
Fundal height measurements and ultrasound scans both help build a picture of how a pregnancy is progressing, but aren’t 100% accurate.

Choosing the birth that felt right

Emma writes:

“Neither option was what I originally wanted, but the thought of potentially spending hours waiting on the ward during an induction really put me off.

I’d found staying on the ward so stressful and overwhelming throughout pregnancy that I knew those weren’t the feelings I wanted to associate with meeting our baby.

I chose a planned caesarean to protect my mental health because, for me, that felt like the safest option for both me and my baby.”

One of the things I really appreciate about Emma’s story is that she doesn’t describe one option as “good” and the other as “bad”.

She weighed up the information she had, thought about her previous experiences during pregnancy and considered what mattered most to her.

For Emma, protecting her mental wellbeing became an important part of making this decision.

That won’t be the deciding factor for every family, and that’s exactly the point.

The “right” decision in pregnancy isn’t always the same for everyone. Your medical history, your baby’s circumstances, your previous experiences and your own priorities all deserve a place in the conversation.

Good maternity care isn’t about making everyone choose the same path.

It’s about making sure you understand your options well enough to choose the path that’s right for you.

A positive planned caesarean birth

Emma continues:

“Leo was born the day before his due date.

Although it wasn’t the birth I’d originally imagined, I actually enjoyed it.

I felt calmer, more in control and less anxious than I’d felt for months.

The whole team, especially the anaesthetist, were wonderful and really put us at ease.

We had our own music playing, delayed cord clamping and immediate skin-to-skin.

Leo weighed 7lb 12oz, so the growth scans had significantly overestimated his size.”

I think this part of Emma’s story is a lovely reminder that a positive birth isn’t defined by how your baby is born.

A planned caesarean can still include many of the things that matter to you. Depending on your circumstances and your hospital’s policies, this may include delayed cord clamping, immediate skin-to-skin, your own music, and other personalised elements that help make the experience feel calm and welcoming.

Birth doesn’t have to look one particular way to be a positive experience.

Feeling informed, listened to and involved in decisions about your care often has a much greater impact on how you remember your birth than the mode of birth itself.

Every pregnancy brings different decisions

Emma’s story won’t be your story.

Your pregnancy may never involve threatened preterm labour, repeated trips to triage or conversations about induction and a planned caesarean.

But almost every pregnancy brings unexpected questions.

You’ll receive information you’ve never had to interpret before.

You’ll weigh up benefits and drawbacks.

You’ll make decisions that nobody else can make for you.

That’s why I believe preparing for birth is about so much more than learning what happens during labour.

It’s about understanding enough to feel confident navigating pregnancy from the very beginning, even when it takes an unexpected turn.

Emma didn’t have the birth she’d imagined at the start of pregnancy.

She had something just as important.

The knowledge and confidence to make informed decisions at every stage of her journey.

To me, that’s what a positive birth is really about.

Looking for more personalised support during pregnancy?

Emma attended my antenatal classes, which gave her the knowledge and confidence to understand her options throughout pregnancy and birth.

For some families, that’s exactly the right level of support.

Others want someone alongside them throughout the journey.

As a birth doula, I provide continuity of support throughout pregnancy, helping you make sense of new information, prepare for appointments, explore your options and navigate unexpected twists with confidence. Rather than facing each new question on your own, you’ll have someone who knows your story and can help you understand the evidence and the choices available to you.

Every pregnancy is different.

Whether everything goes exactly as expected or your plans change along the way, my role is to help you feel informed, supported and confident in the decisions you make.

Find out more about my Birth Doula support

Just found out you’re pregnant? Explore From Two Lines™ and discover why pregnancy preparation starts from the very beginning.

Similar Posts