I’ve fitted the BabyBjörn Mini with lots of newborns, and I keep seeing the same problems. I can usually help parents improve the fit – but when they try other carriers in a consultation, almost all of them choose something else.
Jilly Clarke, babywearing consultant in Welwyn Hatfield, Hertfordshire; and founder of CubCare
The BabyBjörn is one of the newborn carriers I see most often in babywearing consultations.
Sometimes parents have bought one because BabyBjörn is a familiar brand and the Mini is widely stocked. Sometimes they’ve been given one by a friend. Most often they’ve booked because they can’t get it to feel right and want help with the fit.
But I purposely don’t stock any BabyBjörn carriers myself. I’ve fitted the Mini with enough babies and parents to see the same limitations repeatedly, and I think there are much more comfortable, adjustable carriers available.
There’s an obvious caveat here: people don’t usually book a babywearing consultation to show me a carrier that’s already working perfectly. The families I see aren’t a representative sample of everyone who owns a BabyBjörn Mini.
But when we improve the fit as much as we can and they then try some alternatives, almost all of the families I’ve worked with prefer something else.
So here’s what I actually think of the BabyBjörn Mini for newborns, the problems I repeatedly see and what I’d choose instead.
Is the BabyBjörn Mini good for newborns?
The BabyBjörn Mini is specifically designed as a newborn carrier.
It can be used from 3.2kg and 53cm. For babies between 3.2kg and 4.5kg, BabyBjörn instructs parents to use additional leg straps to reduce the size of the leg openings.
It’s deliberately simple. You put the harness onto your own body first and then attach the front panel around your baby. That means you don’t need to hold your baby against your body while simultaneously reaching around yourself to fasten the carrier.
I can understand the appeal.
My problem is what you lose in exchange for that simplicity.
Why does my BabyBjörn Mini hurt my back or shoulders?
If your BabyBjörn Mini is hurting your back or shoulders, it doesn’t automatically mean you’ve fitted it incorrectly.
In a consultation, I’ll first look at how you’re wearing it and talk you through any adjustments that could improve the fit. Small changes can make a considerable difference.
But there are limits to what adjustment can change.
The Mini doesn’t have a supportive waistband, so there are fewer options for distributing your baby’s weight across your body. The baby’s position within the carrier can also affect how heavy they feel.
If their weight is hanging down and pulling away from your body rather than being well supported and held close to you, your shoulders and upper back have more work to do.
I’ve talked parents through getting a better fit with their Mini and then watched them try another carrier with the same baby. The difference can be immediate.
The baby hasn’t suddenly become lighter.
We’ve changed how their weight is being carried.
The Izmi Baby Carrier can be adjusted to fit different wearers as well as different-sized babies. Image: Izmi Baby.
Why does my baby feel so heavy in the BabyBjörn Mini?
Part of this comes back to the design of the carrier.
The Mini doesn’t have a waistband. BabyBjörn’s own comparison information shows that its larger carriers add features including a waist belt and padded shoulder straps, and BabyBjörn recommends moving to a carrier with more back support if you want to carry a heavier baby or carry for longer periods.
But I also look at how the baby’s body is supported within the carrier.
The BabyBjörn Mini has a relatively narrow base. The fabric doesn’t extend as far underneath the baby’s thighs as it does in many of the newborn carriers I prefer.
I prefer being able to support more of a newborn’s thighs, with their knees comfortably bent and their weight distributed across a broader area of fabric.
The Izmi Baby Carrier is one example of a carrier that gives me considerably more control over the width and support underneath a newborn’s thighs. I’ll come back to why I prefer it below.
With the Mini, more of the baby’s weight can feel as though it’s hanging down from the carrier.
That’s one reason a relatively small baby can already start to feel surprisingly heavy.
Izmi discount code: get 10% off
You can get 10% off your Izmi baby carrier order with my Izmi discount code CUB10
Disclosure: I’m an Izmi affiliate. My discount code CUB10 gives you 10% off, and I receive commission if you use it. My recommendation is based on my experience fitting these carriers as a babywearing consultant.
There’s a lot of babywearing content online about narrow-based carriers and hip dysplasia, and it can leave parents frightened that they’ve damaged their baby’s hips by using the wrong carrier.
The evidence doesn’t support that conclusion.
The International Hip Dysplasia Institute states that, based on the available evidence, no baby carrier can cause or prevent hip dysplasia.
It does recommend carrying babies with their thighs supported and their hips and knees bent in a spread-squat or M-position, particularly during the first six months while the hips are developing rapidly.
So I prefer that position.
But I’m not looking at a healthy baby in a BabyBjörn Mini and thinking:
“This carrier is going to damage their hips.”
My objection to the narrow base is much more practical.
I can usually help a parent get their baby into a more supported position in another carrier, with more fabric underneath their thighs and their weight distributed differently.
I can get a better fit than this.
The BabyBjörn Mini harness limits how much you can adjust the fit
This is probably my biggest problem with the Mini.
The harness is also one of the features designed to make the carrier simple to use.
You put the harness onto yourself first. The separate front section then clips onto it around the baby.
That means the carrier is already secured to your body before your baby goes into it.
But when I’m helping someone improve their fit, we’re working within that harness system.
With other carriers, I have more adjustments I can talk a parent through. We can change how the carrier sits on their body, how and where the straps travel across them, where the baby sits and how the tension is distributed through the carrier.
That becomes particularly obvious when the same carrier needs to work on two very different adult bodies.
A carrier needs to fit the person wearing it as well as the baby.
There are adjustments we can make to a BabyBjörn Mini.
There are considerably more options with other carriers.
A baby carried facing inwards in an Izmi Baby Carrier, with the carrier supporting their body and thighs. Image: Izmi Baby.
The Babybjorn harness also sits between you and your baby
This is partly personal preference, but it’s another reason the Mini isn’t a carrier I choose to stock.
The harness sits on the parent’s chest and the baby’s front panel attaches over it.
I prefer a carrier where the baby can sit directly against the parent’s body without that harness structure between them.
It’s not a safety issue.
It’s simply not how I prefer to carry a newborn or the design I prefer when helping somebody choose a carrier.
I don’t like the BabyBjörn Mini head support
Newborns need appropriate head and neck support.
BabyBjörn has built a high, adjustable head support into the Mini for exactly that reason, and its instructions tell parents to adjust the straps at the side while ensuring there is enough space around the baby’s head for their airways to remain clear.
My problem is how I see that feature used in real life.
A high panel around a newborn’s head can make it look as though the baby’s head is supposed to be enclosed by the carrier.
It isn’t.
You should be able to see your baby’s face and monitor their position. Their head needs appropriate support without fabric closing around their face.
It’s something I regularly talk parents through when they’re using these carriers.
I prefer newborns to be able to bring their hands towards their face
The structure of the Mini also encourages the baby’s arms through the arm openings at the sides of the carrier.
That’s not the position I generally want for a tiny newborn.
Newborn babies naturally bring their hands up towards their face and head. I prefer a carrier that gives us enough flexibility to support that more tucked newborn position rather than encouraging their arms out through fixed openings.
As babies grow, what they want to do with their arms changes.
With a newborn, I want the carrier to work around the baby rather than deciding where their limbs should go.
Why does the BabyBjörn Mini have leg straps for small newborns?
BabyBjörn tells parents to use the leg straps when their baby weighs between 3.2kg and 4.5kg.
They’re there to reduce the size of the leg openings.
This helps keep a smaller newborn securely contained within the carrier.
It’s part of the manufacturer’s instructions and should be used for babies within that weight range.
I prefer a carrier where we have more ability to adjust the carrier itself around the size and proportions of the newborn.
Two babies who both weigh 4kg can have very different proportions. Being within the carrier’s weight range doesn’t tell me how well that particular carrier is going to fit that particular baby.
The Izmi Baby Carrier is lightweight and allows the baby's legs to move freely while being supported in the carrier. Image: Izmi Baby.
What happens when parents bring a BabyBjörn Mini to a babywearing consultation?
We start with the carrier they’ve brought.
I’m not going to immediately hand somebody another carrier and tell them to buy it.
I’ll look at how they’re using their Mini and talk them through the adjustments I’d suggest. They make those changes themselves, so they can feel what each adjustment does and know how to recreate the fit when they get home.
We’ll look at their baby’s position, where the harness and straps are sitting on their body and how the carrier feels.
We get the best fit we can from the carrier they already own.
Then, if they want to, they can try some alternatives.
That comparison is often far more useful than anything I could tell them.
Almost all of the families who’ve brought a BabyBjörn carrier to one of my consultations and then tried alternatives have decided to sell the BabyBjörn and use something else.
That’s not evidence that nobody gets on with a BabyBjörn Mini.
It’s my experience of fitting the families who come to me for help.
What’s a good alternative to the BabyBjörn Mini?
For a newborn, one of my favourites is the Izmi Baby Carrier.
It’s still a relatively simple buckled carrier, but it gives you much more control over the baby’s position.
The base of the Izmi can be adjusted to fit the baby. There are three marked width settings, but because the panel attaches with Velcro, it can also be positioned between those settings to get a more precise fit.
That means we can adjust the carrier around the newborn in front of us rather than relying on a fixed-width base and additional leg straps for a smaller baby.
I’ve fitted brand-new newborns comfortably in the Izmi, including twins.
I’m an Izmi affiliate and receive commission if you purchase through my link. I recommend the Izmi because of my experience fitting it with babies and parents as a qualified babywearing consultant.
Should I replace my BabyBjörn Mini?
Not simply because you’ve read this article.
If you already have a BabyBjörn Mini, you and your baby are comfortable and you’re getting a good, safe fit, you don’t need to sell it because a babywearing consultant on the internet prefers something else.
But if you’re constantly adjusting it, your shoulders or back hurt, your baby doesn’t seem well supported or you simply can’t get it to feel right, I’d stop assuming you must be doing something wrong.
Get the fit checked.
And, if you can, try some other carriers with your baby.
The difference between carriers can be enormous, and the carrier that’s everywhere in the shops isn’t necessarily the carrier that will work best on your body.
Need help with your BabyBjörn Mini?
If you’re in Welwyn, Hertfordshire or the surrounding area, you can bring the carrier you already own to one of my babywearing consultations.
I’ll look at how you’re using it and talk you through the adjustments I’d suggest, so you know how to get the fit yourself when you get home.
Then, if you want to, you can try some alternatives and feel the difference for yourself.
If you are pregnant or have a new baby and are looking into what products you will need then you might have come across babywearing. This blog is a babywearing for beginners guide. You might have ventured into a local department, or baby store and been overwhelmed with the different carriers with buckles or long…
Looking for the best baby carrier for a newborn? As a babywearing consultant, I regularly fit newborns in different carriers. Here’s why I prefer the Izmi Baby Carrier to the Ergobaby Embrace — particularly for fit, adjustability, temperature and supporting smaller babies.
Wondering whether it’s too hot to use a sling or baby carrier? Learn how to dress your baby, choose the right carrier, spot signs of overheating, and stay comfortable while babywearing in warm weather.
Your toddler can walk, but that doesn’t mean they’re finished being carried. Find out when you might need a toddler carrier, how to tell if your baby carrier still fits and which styles are actually worth buying.
Manage Consent
To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional
Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes.The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.